Peer-Reviewing Research Articles
Providing Constructive and Supportive Feedback as a Peer Reviewer
Who this Course is for
In this workshop, EMBO Press editors work with PhD students, Postdocs or young group leaders on the principles and practicalities of peer review. Topics covered include the role of peer review in publishing reproducible science and the key elements of a good peer review. We also discuss ethical considerations such as conflicts of interest and give guidelines to young scientists how to become good reviewers.
Style of this Course
The workshop takes place over two consecutive mornings:
Day 1: 09:00 to 13:00 (CET/CEST) including breaks
Day 2: 09:00 to 13:00 (CET/CEST) including breaks
The workshop is offered as a highly engaging and practical live training via Zoom, with interactive elements such as case studies, dynamic group work in breakout rooms, and lively discussion sessions to maximise learning and participation.
What you will learn
The session begins with an introduction to the core principles and value of peer review. Participants will gain an understanding of the editorial process, learn about reviewer’s credit systems, and discuss ethical responsibilities (i.e., managing conflicts of interest). Guidance will also be provided on how to establish yourself as a reviewer.
Topics Covered
Values | Definition of peer review | Concept of peer review
This session focuses on practical skills. Participants will learn general review guidelines and explore the key elements of a strong review report. Through a group exercise, participants will collaboratively review a manuscript, applying theoretical concepts in a practical context.
Topics Covered
Review guidelines | Good reporting
The second day focuses on evaluating referee reports and understanding editorial decision-making. Participants will engage in an interactive group exercise to assess referee reports and learn how editors make publication decisions. Guidance will also be provided on how to craft effective, point-by-point responses to referee comments—an essential skill for both reviewers and authors.
Topics Covered
Referee reports| Editorial decisions | Responding to concerns
Training Delivered by Experts
The course is delivered by experienced EMBO Press Editors. For each course, we provide one trainer who brings a unique perspective and in-depth knowledge of the scientific publishing landscape. With expertise spanning various scientific disciplines and a deep understanding of the editorial process, our editors are ideally positioned to provide valuable insights and practical guidance.
The emphasis on effective structuring and respect for author’s constraints has significantly refined my reviewing skills, leaving me more confident in contributing to the scientific peer-review process.
Adrianna Ntogka | PhD Student
University of Cologne
Our Peer review training at your Institute
If you have a group of PhD students, postdocs, or early-stage group leaders who would benefit from developing strong communication and presentation skills, while fostering a collaborative learning environment, we’re happy to bring this course to your institute! Find out how…